Popular narratives regarding the Persian Wars frame them as East versus West, Greeks versus barbarians, and with Greeks cast as defenders of freedom and Persians as cruel despots. This view echoes in pop culture, from textbooks to the graphic novel 300, where Leonidas of Sparta declares "A new age has begun, an age of great deeds, an age of reason, an age of justice, an age of law..."
As stirring as this vision may be, asserts historian Jeremy McInerney, it is deeply flawed. It does not account for the fact that the Persian Empire was one of the largest and most stable of the ancient world, marked by religious tolerance and stunning cultural accomplishments. Stories of Greek exceptionalism overlook that while the Athenians lavishly praised their democratic victory over supposed Persian autocracy in the 5th century, they exercised tyrannical rule over other Greeks.
McInerney offers a new look at both Persians and Greeks to reveal that the Persian Wars were not an inevitable clash of civilizations but the product of miscalculations, logistical challenges, unpredictable politics, and a fatal inability to understand the other side's intentions. It is a story of mistrust and misunderstanding, far more complex and fascinating than the familiar tale of Greek heroism.
McInerney is Christopher H. Browne distinguished professor of classical studies at the University of Pennsylvania.
His book By Land and by Sea: The Persian Wars and the Birth of Classical Greece (Oxford University Press) is available for purchase.
Book Sale Information
General Information